When it comes to home security in Memphis, TN, homeowners often face a critical decision: should you rekey your existing locks or replace them entirely? This question comes up frequently after moving into a new house, experiencing a break-in, or simply wanting to upgrade your security. As experienced locksmith professionals serving Shelby County, Desoto County, and Tipton County, we at Raleigh Memphis Locksmiths help Tennessee residents make this important decision every day. Understanding the difference between these two service options can save you money while ensuring your home remains safe and secure.
Understanding the Concept of Rekeying
Rekeying is a locksmith service that involves changing the internal pins and springs inside your existing lock cylinder so that a new key operates it. The original key will no longer work after this process is complete. This is a popular service in Memphis because it's typically cheaper than full lock replacement while still providing excellent security benefits. When our locksmith team performs a rekey service, we're essentially making your existing hardware work with a different key configuration, which means you don't need to replace the entire lock mechanism or door hardware.
The process is fast and can usually be completed on-site at your residential property. Our professional locksmiths can perform this service quickly, often rekeying multiple locks in a single visit to ensure all your doors work with one key for convenience.
When to Choose Rekeying
Rekeying is the ideal solution in several common situations that Memphis homeowners face:
- Moving into a new home or house: You never know how many copies of the original key are circulating from previous owners, contractors, or real estate agents
- After a roommate moves out: When an individual who had access to your home is no longer living there
- Lost or stolen keys: If you've misplaced your keys or they were stolen without a break-in occurring
- Employee turnover: For those running a business from home or commercial property
- Wanting a master key system: Making all your locks work with one convenient key
- When locks are in good condition: If your existing door hardware functions properly and meets current security standards
Understanding Lock Replacement
Lock replacement involves removing your existing lock hardware completely and installing a new lock system on your door. This service is more comprehensive than rekeying and is necessary in certain situations where rekeying simply won't perform adequately. When you replace a lock, you're getting entirely new components, which can include upgraded security features, different styles, or modern technology like smart locks.
Our Memphis locksmith experts can help you select the best lock options for your residential, commercial, or automotive needs. We're known for providing quality products at fair prices without the excessive charge you might encounter from a dealer or larger chain services like Pop-A-Lock, Good People Locksmithing, Mr Lockout, Key Man, Lockman, or Atech.
When to Choose Lock Replacement
There are specific situations where replacing your locks is the better option:
- Damaged or worn locks: When locks are stuck, keys break off inside, or the mechanism is incomplete
- After a break-in: Police often recommend upgrading security after an attempted or successful burglary
- Upgrading security: Moving to higher-grade locks with better security ratings
- Style updates: When renovating and wanting modern hardware that matches your new aesthetic
- Incompatible locks: When you want all locks to match but have different brands that can't be rekeyed to work together
- Smart lock installation: Upgrading to keyless entry or smart home integration
- Excessive wear: When locks have been used for many years and internal components are worn
Cost Comparison: Rekey vs. Replace
Budget is often a major factor for Memphis homeowners making this decision. Generally speaking, rekeying is significantly cheaper than replacement because you're keeping the existing hardware and only changing the internal configuration. A typical rekey service costs a fraction of what you'd pay for new locks, making it an attractive option when security is the primary concern but the locks themselves are in good condition.
Lock replacement costs more because you're paying for new hardware, the locksmith's service time, and installation. However, this investment might be worthwhile if you're gaining enhanced security features, better quality locks, or solving problems with damaged hardware. At Raleigh Memphis Locksmiths, we believe in providing transparent pricing with no hidden charge, ensuring Memphis residents get the best value for their security investment.
Security Considerations
Both rekeying and replacing locks can provide excellent security when done properly by a professional locksmith. The key difference isn't necessarily the level of security you achieve, but rather the condition and quality of what you're working with. A properly rekeyed lock on a high-quality door can be just as safe as a newly installed lock. However, if your current locks are low-grade or damaged, replacement with higher-security options might be necessary to truly protect your home.
Our locksmith team serving Memphis, TN can evaluate your current security setup and recommend whether rekeying will provide adequate protection or if replacement is necessary. We service residential, commercial, automotive, and even motorcycle locks, ensuring comprehensive security solutions.
Additional Services for Memphis Homeowners
Beyond rekeying and replacement, Raleigh Memphis Locksmiths offers a full range of locksmith services throughout the Memphis area:
- Emergency lockout service: 24-hour help for residential, car, and commercial lockouts
- Key duplication: Making duplicate keys for home, auto, or business
- Master key systems: Developing systems for rental properties or multi-unit buildings
- Safe installation and unlocking: Providing security for valuables
- Automotive locksmith service: Car key replacement, transponder programming, and vehicle unlocking
- Commercial security: High-security lock installation for business properties
Making the Right Choice for Your Memphis Home
The decision between rekeying and replacing ultimately depends on your individual situation, budget, and security needs. Here's a simple way to think about it: if your locks are functioning well and you simply need to control who has access, rekeying is probably your best option. If your locks are damaged, outdated, or you want to upgrade your security system, replacement makes more sense.
Don't trust just any locksmith with your home security. Choose a local, professional service that understands Memphis neighborhoods and the specific security challenges Tennessee residents face. We're not located in California or operating from some distant call centerβwe're your local Memphis locksmith experts, providing quality service to your community.
Get Expert Locksmith Service in Memphis Today
Still unsure whether to rekey or replace your locks? The best approach is to consult with an experienced locksmith who can assess your specific situation. At Raleigh Memphis Locksmiths, we provide free on-site evaluations and quotes for all residential, commercial, and automotive locksmith needs. Our professional team is available 24 hours a day for emergency service, and we pride ourselves on fast response times throughout the Memphis metro area.
Don't compromise on your family's security or pay excessive prices for incomplete service from inexperienced providers. Trust the local experts who are known for providing quality workmanship at fair prices. Whether you need help with lockouts, key making, security upgrades, or simply can't decide between rekeying and replacing, we're here to help.
Call Raleigh Memphis Locksmiths today at (901) 676-7213 to speak with our locksmith professionals. We'll help you make the right choice for your Memphis home's security needs. Our phone lines are available 24/7, and our mobile service truck can reach you quickly anywhere in the 901 area. Contact us for a quote and experience the difference that professional, local locksmith service makes!

